Can't enable AFP share indexing on macOS

[gegtor]

I'm trying to enable spotlight indexing on my AFP FreeNAS share and it returns indexing disabled or unknown indexing state

I tried everything aka everything that i found on google

I think that it's something to do with my share permissions not with my indexing because
a) indexing works fine on my boot drive and my old synology server but not on FreeNAS
b) i get the same error on all my macs

Here is some data:
When i try to enable indexing is says Indexing disabled or unknown indexing state:

Here are share permissions when mounted on my mac:

Dataset permissions:

AFP Share permission settings:

 

[gegtor]

macOS Sierra 10.12.6

 

[dlavigne]

Were you able to figure this out?

 

[gegtor]

https://apple.stackexchange.com/que...h-mdutil-i-on-with-sierra-not-working-anymore

Yup