Going back to 11.1 made everything work again. I'm going to go through and update to 11.2, then 11.3 and then again to 12 to see where it breaks and try to figure out why. I seem to recall my Backup being upgraded to 11.2 and then 11.3 and remained working with no issues during that process last year. If I ca get my main server up to 11.3 then I'll probably be fine for another span of time.
(edit) BTW, I have 120gb system drives in this machine, so I can hold on to a lot of old installs.