Hi.

Status
Not open for further replies.

DaChaos

Dabbler
Joined
Mar 11, 2016
Messages
11
Just wanted to join the community since I recently installed FreeNAS on an older computer.
Threw 4 x 4TB RED (mirrored 0 + 1) & 2 USB sticks & I'm impressed with how easy it is to use & setup FreeNAS, decent performance.
I know not recommended to use old hardware but I at least meet the 8GB requirements on old XPS 8100.
Running great so far. Still messing with some of the new features to me. Documentation is helpful.
Thanks.
 

BigDave

FreeNAS Enthusiast
Joined
Oct 6, 2013
Messages
2,479
Welcome to the forums DeChaos!
 

gpsguy

Active Member
Joined
Jan 22, 2012
Messages
4,472
Welcome to the forums! And, thanks for reading the documentation.
 

Mirfster

Doesn't know what he's talking about
Joined
Oct 2, 2015
Messages
3,215
Welcome.
I know not recommended to use old hardware but I at least meet the 8GB requirements on old XPS 8100.
Please take some time to get familiarized with the some of the documentation and hardware requirements. I have some of the most recommended reading items made by contributors linked in my signature. Before you get too seriously involved and start putting vital data on you FreeNas, it would serve you best to get as much knowledge as possible up front.

Just guessing that this is an "evaluation" for you so I won't go pinging you too much on the fact that your system does not have ECC Ram. ;)
 

DaChaos

Dabbler
Joined
Mar 11, 2016
Messages
11
Thanks for the welcome.

Yea, I read the warning label. Can I be a risk taker? I'm mostly just using it for plex streaming currently. Haven't put anything critical.

I'll read some more but is there anything I can do about not having ECC ram? It's either have ECC or don't use FreeNAS?

I planned to make backups on Amazon S3 & DVDs for critical photos etc if this makes it ok?

Will be a bit before I can upgrade server hardware. I just finally replaced that XPS 8100 & it was like 8yrs old.

I love how easy FreeNAS is & Windows kinda sucks these days unless your gaming & doesn't recognize my 4TB HD.

I've tried setting up my own nas on Debian & I can probably get it going kinda savvy & know a thing or 2 from web servers & a bit of programming.
But will take awhile to get it setup to be close to as great as FreeNAS lol.

Any suggestions? Spent too much on my gaming rig. I could repurpose the extra hardware & just put some of those HD in my gaming rig if I'm just wasting my time. I haven't gotten too involved yet but I like it.

I mostly just didn't want my gaming computer to be bothered with being a nas while I'm gaming & don't want the old hardware to go to waste.

--- new gaming rig if u were wondering ---
AMD FX-8350 OC @ 5Ghz cpu
ASUS Crosshair Formula-Z motherboard
32 GB DDR3 corsair vengeance @ 1866 ram
Radeon Fury-X Water-cooled video
BENQ 27" 1440p LED monitor
Corsair H110i GTX CPU Watercooler
Sound Blaster-Z audio
Samsung 850 EVO Pro 512GB SSD
WD Black 3TB HDD
 

DaChaos

Dabbler
Joined
Mar 11, 2016
Messages
11
Looks like some good reads & can probably answer my own questions so u don't have to again :p
I know communities don't like repeating themselves. So on to more research :)

edit:
always good to start at the rules
"Questions revolving around ECC/non-ECC RAM. There is already a very thorough forum sticky on this topic."
 
Last edited:

DaChaos

Dabbler
Joined
Mar 11, 2016
Messages
11
Crazy how that works. Never really had problems with non ECC before. But after reading that it doesn't sound like a risk, sounds more like insanity to want to go without ECC on ZFS... The part that was a deal breaker for me is corrupting backups & no recovery.

For the time being I think I'll still use FreeNAS only to host plex & movies. Ill keep the other files on my gaming PC & use FreeNAS for Backup File History Server

Edit:
You spend enough time on the forums & you see all the others that have tried & failed before me LOL.
SMH well this is may be an evaluation. Until I can upgrade hardware. One of the main reasons for setting this up was reliability. If I oddly keep freenas ill be sure to match 1 TB hd to 1 GB ram. I read about. Keep up the good work guys. Thanks for the suggestions.
 
Last edited:

Bidule0hm

Server Electronics Sorcerer
Joined
Aug 5, 2013
Messages
3,710
I'll read some more but is there anything I can do about not having ECC ram? It's either have ECC or don't use FreeNAS?

No; and no but it's a non-null risk to lose all your data because of RAM errors, pretty rare but it has already happened to multiple members in the past. Personally I'd never use FreeNAS without ECC RAM but you can take the risk if you want, your data, your choice ;)

I planned to make backups on Amazon S3 & DVDs for critical photos etc if this makes it ok?

If you keep all your backups then yes but if you keep only the last backup then no because you'll probably have a corrupted backup because you'll have copied the corrupted data to the backup.

Crazy how that works. Never really had problems with non ECC before. But after reading that it doesn't sound like a risk, sounds more like insanity to want to go without ECC on ZFS... The part that was a deal breaker for me is corrupting backups & no recovery.

Because usually you don't even know the problem is because of RAM error(s). When you see Windows BSOD you just think "well, it's Windows, nothing new here..." or when you hear a glitch in your musics or see a glitch in your movies you think it's here from the first time you had the file and you don't care much about it, etc...

If you keep multiple backups then it should be ok in case the last one(s) is(are) corrupted you can still recover your data from an older backup.

ill be sure to match 1 TB hd to 1 GB ram.

Don't be too concerned about that, it's a flexible rule, you can have 20 TB of data with 8 GB of RAM without any problems for example (NB: if you use Plex then you really should have 16 GB of RAM minimum) so use it as a guideline but not a hard rule :)
 

Bidule0hm

Server Electronics Sorcerer
Joined
Aug 5, 2013
Messages
3,710
You're welcome ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top