File/Dictorectory User Issues

[gwaitsi]

Below user permissions via an smb shares gives me;
- can create directory / cannot delete directoy [desired]
- can create file / can delete file [not desired - should be cannot delete]

If i uncheck append, I can't create directories, yet I cannot delete files.
Something doesn't seem right with the way these work.

 

[anodos]

This is correct behavior per NFS4 RFCs. There are various situations where users can override file permissions (such as being owner of file). Generally though removing DELETE | DELETE_CHILD is not a great option for SMB shares (if this is where you're doing this) since it will prevent file renames.

 

[gwaitsi]

This is correct behavior per NFS4 RFCs. There are various situations where users can override file permissions (such as being owner of file). Generally though removing DELETE | DELETE_CHILD is not a great option for SMB shares (if this is where you're doing this) since it will prevent file renames.

screenshot is from the dataset

 

[anodos]

screenshot is from the dataset

const ACE4_APPEND_DATA = 0x00000004;
const ACE4_ADD_SUBDIRECTORY = 0x00000004;

APPEND_DATA and ADD_SUDIRECTORY share a mask. C.F. RFC 3530 section 5.11. It may be helpful for webui to report on all values sharing mask, but that would quickly become a wall of tex.