Never updated since 2014, paid the price. Should I keep my CPU/Mobo or start fresh?

altspacen

Cadet
Joined
Jul 25, 2022
Messages
2
Hey there!
Been a FreeNAS user since late 2014. The build was as follows -
CPU - XEON E3-1245V2
Mobo - SUPERMICRO MBD-X9SCM-F-O-RF
HDD - WD Red 3TB (6)
RAM - 16GB DDR3 ECC (1)
OS Drive - 8GB Flash stick
Case - NANOXIA DEEPSILENCE4 ATX CASE

The thing ran great until I tried to update the server about 3 years ago and somehow lost all of the GUI data, but the server's backend still ran fine. I then tried to update Plex about 2 years ago and borked it all up (I had previously done it once through the console and was successful). Then one, or possibly two, drive(s) decided to make some terrible noise, so I shut it down about a year ago and let the whole thing collect dust.

On it, I ran Plex as a media server and some associated goodies to automate my library accumulation. Sab/Sonarr/CouchPotato/SickBeard/Transmission. I also hosted some files that were backed up to the cloud. I'm okay with losing all data on that box and starting over. The thing is, I'd like to do it with larger drives. This leaves me with the choice:

Do I keep the hardware I have currently, or 86 the whole project and start anew? My media habits include large-size files as I put them through a theater and usually try to get as high quality as I can muster. But sometimes, I'll let the server transcode whatever it needs to, as there is some remote access to Plex, and those boxes requesting access to files don't always accommodate the container they're in. Also, Plex always seemed to transcode when adding subtitles on the fly, regardless of the container. The system had no issues running 1080p files, though it had issues working with 4K files.

The rest of the storage is for media files for content creation that I've landed a gig with and need to store these 4k 10-bit raw videos on. I'm so astonished that my current previous NAS from 8 years ago is outshined by a single external drive. It's wild.

If needed - the budget for new hardware (less drives) is less than $1k USD. Should I just put new drives in my existing hardware from '14 and start fresh there, start over with a new build, or combo the 2 options and have the NAS be a location that a wilder setup would use for Plex and its associated automation (I don't think that's as justifiable an answer as either of the other 2 options though)? Open to some assistance. Thanks.
 

Redcoat

MVP
Joined
Feb 18, 2014
Messages
2,925
Welcome to the forums!

See my signature - I have two systems similar to yours running very well and assume that yours, maybe with a memory upgrade to 32gig, will do "just fine" for you with new drives. I suppose you could also consider adding an HBA to run all 6 drives from SATAIII ports. I would dump the flash boot drive and use a small SSD (use a USB to SATA adapter for the SSD if you don't have an open SATA port).

As whatever HDD's you use will be "fully transplantable" to a new system should you decide to invest in one, this is a low-cost, low risk, starting point for your "get re-aquainted" trip with Free/TrueNAS.

Good luck.
 
Last edited:

altspacen

Cadet
Joined
Jul 25, 2022
Messages
2
Welcome to the forums!

See my signature - I have two systems similar to yours running very well and assume that yours, maybe with a memory upgrade to 32gig, will do "just fine" for you with new drives. I suppose you could also consider adding an HBA to run all 6 drives from SATAIII ports. I would dump the flash boot drive and use a small SSD (use a USB to SATA adapter for the SSD if you don't have an open SATA port).

As whatever HDD's you use will be "fully transplantable" to a new system should you decide to invest in one, this is a low-cost, low risk, starting point for your "get re-aquainted" trip with Free/TrueNAS.

Good luck.
Since I've been out of the game for some time, I need to look into HBA (what it means, how to implement it, or its hardware, or whatever). That mobo has 4x SATA2 and 2x SATA3 and I never really bothered with the difference in speed, putting the whole server at SATA2 speeds on the ZFS pool. I do not have an open SATA port, but I have open USB headers on the board, which is what I'm running the flash drive from.

I know at least 2 of my 3TB drives are not going to make it; with all that data I had on the NAS being expendable, I know I'll get much larger drives. I'm on the fence about my hardware from 8 years ago and if that will support the needs of 2022 and beyond, or if starting anew from here would be a better bet. Looking at several members' signatures, it ranges from about this age range to newer. I did buy those items new in '14, so it's not like they had prior use.

I'll look into another RAM stick, though. If what I have is sufficient, that's an easy upgrade.
 
Top