BUILD Hard drive recommendations

djdwosk97

Patron
Joined
Jun 12, 2015
Messages
382
I'm looking to expand my current setup (currently three 4TB CMR Reds and one HGST5K40001). They're currently not in any form of RAID (I know, not ideal), and I don't foresee myself buying 4 additional 4TB drives to switch to a Z2 configuration (with an additional 8TB of storage). I was thinking about buying a single 8-14 TB drive. I'm wondering if there are any current reliability benefits to one capacity over another (I remember long ago that drives with 1.5TB platters tended to be less reliable than others, but I don't know if there is still some similar phenomenon).
There are obviously other pros/cons to larger/smaller drives, but that's something else that I'll have to give some thought over before making my final decision.

Current options that I've come across:
  • 4x 4TB Iron Wolf -- $420 (Combined into a Z2 array with my 3 existing CMR 4TB Reds and 1 HGST5k400001).
  • 1x 8TB WD Red -- $205
  • 1x 12TB WD Red -- $305
  • 1x 8TB WD Ultrastar HC320 (HUS728T8TALE6L4) -- $175
  • 1x 8TB Seagate Exos 7E8 (ST8000NM0055) -- $190
  • 1x 12TB Seagate Exos x12 -- (ST12000NM0007) -- $275
  • 1x 14TB Seagate Exos x14 (ST14000NM0018) -- $305
I'm leaning towards the 8tb Seagate 7E8, 8tb Ultrastar HC320, or 12tb x12.

P.s. I might end up putting two of the 4TB Reds in a mirror configuration for the most important data (currently on a mirrored pair of Blues) assuming I go with a single drive route.

P.p.s I was also considering a WD Easystore 8/10/12 if these still have CMR Whites (Reds), but I would also need to replace my PSU since it doesn't support the SATA 3 spec regarding the 3.3v pin and I'm not interested in modding/taping molex connectors, so that route is likely to be less cost effective.
 
Last edited:
Top