ACLs seem to break smb access

[hall.christopher88]

I poked on these for about 2 hours today.

On smb share If i add acls for owner@ group@ and everyone with explicit allow full control permission denied happens. Truenas calls this set 'open'

Stripping acls off everything works properly.

Bonus problem when everything works properly with the smb share from windows. On linux i can do everything except copy folders into it. I can make folders and move files but copy folders doesnt work

 

[hall.christopher88]

I took some screenshots to illustrate what I am talking about

If I leave it on stripped ACLS the files are wide open to everyone and anyone

The moment I take everyone off the ACL, I can no longer access the share or files, regardless of what credentials I feed it. This makes me think it is not actually using the credentials I feed it but using some other user to get at the share from windows
If I try to change the credentials for the share acl instead of the files acl,whatever changes I make are not saved and it always reverts to no domain user everyone


Truenas 12, all updates
Windows 10