My reasons for have to replace both 500gig drives are I have two data ports. There is no room for a third drive. Yes I could buy a PCI SATA Adapter but I have put a good bit of money already into the system and it’s main purpose is a Plex machine so nothing mission critical is on it. I shucked the drive out of a sea gate external enclosure so I have the piece that turns the hard drive into a sun drive basically and that’s what I planned on using to transfer the data onto the drive. I’ve already upgraded the drives before this way and it worked but I replaced 2 drives with 2 drives. Never two to one.